Invite Friend
Invite Your Friend click on given below links
Invite Friend
Invite Your Friend click on given below links
Invite Friend
Invite Your Friend click on given below links
Free Demo Class
Register for Free Demo Lecture & Test Series
Thank you for your registration.
For latest materials & updates keep visiting our website.
Failed to register. Please try again later!
The debate over whether old NCERTs or new NCERTs are better for UPSC preparation is a perennial topic among aspirants. With the Civil Services Examination (CSE) demanding a strong foundation in subjects like History, Geography, Polity, and Economy, NCERT textbooks remain a cornerstone of preparation. However, the differences between the old editions (published roughly between the 1980s and early 2000s) and the new editions (post-2005, aligned with the updated curriculum) often leave candidates confused. This article aims to provide clarity by comparing the two, highlighting their strengths and weaknesses, and offering practical advice for UPSC aspirants.
The National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT) periodically revises its textbooks to reflect updated syllabi, pedagogical approaches, and factual accuracy. The "old NCERTs" refer to editions authored by renowned scholars like R.S. Sharma (History), Satish Chandra (Medieval History), and Bipan Chandra (Modern History), among others, while the "new NCERTs" are more recent, streamlined versions designed for school students under the National Curriculum Framework (NCF) of 2005.
Here’s a breakdown of the key differences:
Content Depth and Style
Old NCERTs: Known for their detailed, analytical, and narrative-driven approach, these books were written by subject matter experts with a focus on conceptual clarity. For example, R.S. Sharma’s Ancient India provides an in-depth exploration of historical processes, making it a favorite among aspirants.
New NCERTs: These are more concise, student-friendly, and fact-based, with less emphasis on analysis. They cater to modern teaching methods, often using visuals and simplified language, such as in Our Pasts (History) or Contemporary India (Geography).
Language and Accessibility
Old NCERTs: The language can be dense and academic, which might feel challenging for beginners but rewarding for those seeking deeper insights.
New NCERTs: Written in simpler, more engaging language, they are easier to read and understand, especially for aspirants new to UPSC preparation.
Coverage of Topics
Old NCERTs: They often cover topics in greater detail, sometimes including perspectives or details omitted in newer versions. For instance, the old History NCERTs delve into socio-economic contexts extensively.
New NCERTs: Aligned with the current school curriculum, they focus on core topics relevant to the UPSC syllabus but may skip some nuanced details found in older editions.
Availability
Old NCERTs: Hard to find in print, aspirants often rely on second-hand copies, photocopies, or PDFs circulating online.
New NCERTs: Easily available on the NCERT website, bookstores, or as free downloads, making them more accessible.
The relevance of old versus new NCERTs varies by subject. Let’s explore this:
History
Old NCERTs: R.S. Sharma (Ancient), Satish Chandra (Medieval), and Bipan Chandra (Modern) are gold standards for their depth and analytical rigor. They’re especially useful for Mains, where conceptual understanding is key.
New NCERTs: Books like Our Pasts (Classes 6-8) and Themes in Indian History (Class 12) are concise and good for Prelims but lack the depth needed for Mains answers.
Verdict: Old NCERTs are preferred for History, especially for serious aspirants aiming to master the subject.
Geography
Old NCERTs: Books like Lands and Peoples or Physical Geography by Savindra Singh (though not strictly NCERT) were detailed but are now outdated in some aspects.
New NCERTs: Fundamentals of Physical Geography (Class 11) and India: Physical Environment (Class 11) are up-to-date, visually rich, and syllabus-aligned.
Verdict: New NCERTs are better for Geography due to updated data and clarity.
Polity
Old NCERTs: Limited in scope and outdated compared to modern requirements.
New NCERTs: Democratic Politics (Classes 9-10) and Indian Constitution at Work (Class 11) provide a solid base for understanding governance and the Constitution.
Verdict: New NCERTs suffice, though most aspirants supplement with M. Laxmikanth.
Economy
Old NCERTs: Less relevant due to outdated economic data and policies.
New NCERTs: Indian Economic Development (Class 11) and Introductory Macroeconomics (Class 12) offer a modern perspective.
Verdict: New NCERTs are more suitable, paired with current affairs.
Old NCERTs
Pros: Rich in detail, excellent for conceptual clarity, favored by toppers for History and optional subjects.
Cons: Outdated in parts, harder to source, and time-consuming for beginners.
New NCERTs
Pros: Easy to read, widely available, updated with recent changes, ideal for quick revision.
Cons: Lack depth for Mains, overly simplified for some topics.
The choice between old and new NCERTs depends on your preparation stage, time availability, and goals:
Beginners: Start with new NCERTs (Classes 6-12) to build a basic understanding. Their simplicity helps you grasp concepts without feeling overwhelmed.
Intermediate Learners: Gradually incorporate old NCERTs, especially for History, to deepen your knowledge and prepare for Mains.
Advanced Aspirants: Use a mix of both—new NCERTs for quick revision and old NCERTs for detailed insights, particularly in History and optional subjects.
Time Constraint: If you’re short on time, stick to new NCERTs and supplement with standard reference books (e.g., Laxmikanth for Polity, Spectrum for Modern History).
Prioritize Syllabus: Cross-check NCERT content with the UPSC syllabus to focus on relevant chapters.
Supplement Wisely: NCERTs are foundational, not exhaustive. Pair them with current affairs and standard books.
Digital Resources: Use PDFs of old NCERTs if physical copies are unavailable, but verify their authenticity.
Revision: Regardless of the edition, revise multiple times—UPSC tests retention, not just reading.
Neither old nor new NCERTs are universally "better"—they serve different purposes. Old NCERTs shine for their depth and analytical edge, making them invaluable for History and Mains preparation, while new NCERTs excel in accessibility, updated content, and ease of use, especially for Prelims and subjects like Geography and Economy. The smart approach is to blend the two strategically, tailoring your booklist to your strengths and weaknesses. Ultimately, it’s not about the edition but how well you understand and apply the knowledge to crack the UPSC exam.
